A Democratic congressional candidate in Pennsylvania has drawn criticism from his Republican opponent after publicly disparaging President Trump’s overtime tax break, even as his national union organization has endorsed the policy.
Bob Brooks, who serves as president of the Pennsylvania Professional Firefighters Association and is running for Congress in Pennsylvania’s competitive swing district against Republican Representative Ryan Mackenzie, voiced concerns about the One Big Beautiful Bill Act during an appearance on a podcast in May. His criticism has created an apparent conflict with the position of his parent organization, the International Association of Firefighters.
The legislation in question provides a maximum annual deduction of $12,500 on qualified overtime compensation, with the benefit phasing out after $150,000 of gross income for individual filers or $300,000 for joint filers, according to the Internal Revenue Service.
During his podcast appearance, Brooks took issue with how the administration has promoted the policy, specifically referencing a December rally in Mount Pocono where President Trump featured a first responder on stage. Brooks claimed the individual was not a paid firefighter and suggested that ninety percent of firefighters would not benefit from the overtime tax break.
However, the individual in question was indeed a paid police officer in Monroe County who also serves as a volunteer firefighter. As a law enforcement officer, he would qualify for the no tax on overtime provision in his paid first responder capacity.
The criticism stands in notable contrast to the position taken by the International Association of Firefighters, the national organization under which Brooks’s state association operates. IAFF President Edward Kelly has publicly supported the Republican tax policies, specifically praising the elimination of taxes on qualified overtime pay.
Kelly characterized the overtime provision as a needed reform for the organization’s 350,000 members, whose demanding profession requires long hours and irregular schedules. He stated that firefighters and emergency medical workers should not face financial penalties for choosing careers in public service, and commended President Trump for recognizing the importance of allowing these workers to retain more of their earnings.
The Fraternal Order of Police has similarly expressed support for the legislation through official correspondence to members of Congress.
Brooks’s campaign maintains that his position is more nuanced than his opponent suggests, and has accused the Republican of policies that actually harm first responders. The Democrat from Nazareth has built his congressional campaign partly on his extensive background as a former Bethlehem firefighter and his leadership roles within the union structure.
The dispute over the overtime tax break has emerged as a significant issue in what political observers consider a toss-up race. The disagreement between a state union leader and his national organization over a policy directly affecting their membership adds an unusual dimension to an already competitive contest.
The race represents one of several swing district battles that could prove decisive in determining control of the House of Representatives. Both candidates are working to position themselves as the stronger advocate for first responders and working-class constituents in the district.
Related: Kennedy Denounces Report on His Management of Health Department
