Thirty years after Susan Smith drowned her two young sons in a South Carolina lake, a seven-member parole board will convene Thursday to consider whether she should be released from prison. Her ex-husband has made his position clear: she should remain incarcerated until her death.

David Smith, now 56, spoke publicly ahead of the hearing regarding his former wife’s request for parole in the 1994 murders of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander. His statement was direct and unequivocal. He wants Susan Smith to serve the remainder of her natural life behind bars, noting that three decades have done nothing to diminish the pain of losing his children.

The circumstances of this case shocked the nation when they came to light. Smith secured her two young boys in their car seats and allowed the vehicle to roll into a lake, drowning them both. Prosecutors at trial argued that she committed these murders at least in part because the man with whom she was having an extramarital affair did not want a relationship with a woman who had children. The jury convicted her on two counts of murder in 1995, resulting in a life sentence.

Under South Carolina law as it existed in 1994, individuals sentenced to life imprisonment could be considered for parole after serving 30 years. Susan Smith has now reached that threshold. However, state lawmakers changed this statute shortly after her conviction. Anyone sentenced to life for murders committed after January 1, 1996, is permanently ineligible for parole. Smith’s crime occurred just days before this cutoff date would have applied.

The defense team during her trial painted a different picture of the events, arguing that Smith was experiencing severe depression and existed in a fragile mental state. They characterized the drownings as a failed suicide attempt in which she had intended to take her own life along with those of her sons. The jury rejected this argument.

David Smith’s ordeal included a particularly cruel deception. He initially believed his then-wife’s account of events, only to learn the truth about what she had done to their children while watching television coverage of the case. The revelation came to him not in private but through public broadcast, adding another layer of trauma to an already devastating situation.

As the parole hearing approaches, David Smith has been forthright about his observations of his ex-wife over the past three decades. He stated that he has never sensed genuine remorse from her, noting that she has never expressed any such sentiment to him directly. This absence of contrition factors prominently in his opposition to her release.

The case serves as a reminder of how the criminal justice system balances the concepts of punishment, rehabilitation, and the rights of victims’ families. While the law provides Susan Smith the opportunity to request parole, it equally provides her ex-husband and the families of the victims the chance to be heard. The seven members of the parole board now face the responsibility of weighing these considerations against the nature of the crimes committed and the decades that have passed since that tragic day in 1994.

Related: Illegal Immigrant Uber Driver Charged with Assault of Minor in California