A twenty-four-year-old homeless man has confessed to setting fire to a historic Brooklyn church and has been charged with federal arson, according to court documents filed this week by federal prosecutors.
John Jones was arrested Wednesday and admitted to law enforcement officials that he deliberately ignited the South Bushwick Reformed Church on June 19, triggering a three-alarm fire that destroyed the 173-year-old house of worship. The blaze consumed the church’s historic spire, causing it to collapse, and destroyed thousands of historic artifacts housed within the building.
The case has taken a more disturbing turn as prosecutors revealed that Jones maintained a notebook containing detailed lists of potential targets for violence. According to the federal detention memo, the notebook included a chart with handwritten categories such as “murder them,” “kill them,” “stab them,” “make them pay,” and “rape him.” The chart contained tally marks and repeated misspellings of the word “church,” suggesting a pattern of planned attacks.
“The defendant admitted to committing the church arson for which he has been charged in this case,” the detention memo states. “Furthermore, the defendant stated that he had recently attempted to burn down a second church in Brooklyn, New York.”
Surveillance footage proved instrumental in linking Jones to the crime. Video evidence captured Jones attempting to enter the church but being denied access. He then crossed the street to purchase a lighter before returning to the side of the building. Shortly thereafter, surveillance cameras recorded a large plume of smoke rising from the structure.
Jones now faces a maximum sentence of twenty years in federal prison if convicted. Prosecutors have requested that he be held without bail, citing the severity of the crime and the threat he poses to public safety. He is scheduled to be arraigned Friday.
New York Police Department Commissioner Jessica Tisch addressed the gravity of the incident in a statement released Thursday. “This defendant placed countless Brooklyn residents at risk when he recklessly set fire to the South Bushwick Reformed Church in broad daylight,” Commissioner Tisch said. “New Yorkers deserve to practice their faith freely and without fear, and the destruction of this sacred New York City landmark will be met with swift justice.”
Local residents have expressed profound sadness over the loss of the historic structure. The South Bushwick Reformed Church had stood as a cornerstone of the community for nearly two centuries, serving generations of worshipers and preserving irreplaceable historical records and artifacts.
The three-alarm fire required significant resources to contain and left six firefighters injured as they battled the stubborn flames that gutted much of the church’s interior. The building’s structural integrity has been severely compromised, and the full extent of the historical loss continues to be assessed.
The case underscores growing concerns about attacks on religious institutions and the safety of houses of worship across the nation. Federal authorities are treating this matter with the utmost seriousness, reflecting the broader implications for religious freedom and community security.
As this case proceeds through the federal court system, it will serve as a test of how effectively our justice system can respond to acts of violence against sacred spaces and the communities they serve.
Related: Investigation Underway After Decomposing Remains Found at Chicago Funeral Facility
