States that choose not to participate in the Education Freedom Tax Credit program stand to lose nearly $23 billion in education funding over the next three years, according to a new analysis released this week.
The America First Policy Institute has developed detailed projections showing the financial impact on states that decline to opt in to the federal tax credit initiative. The analysis focuses on charitable donations for education that would be directed to participating states through the EFTC program.
To illustrate these potential losses, the institute will launch an interactive Funding Loss Calculator. This tool will allow citizens and policymakers to examine state-by-state projections of forfeited funding, providing transparency about the financial consequences of non-participation.
Erika Donalds, representing the America First Policy Institute, emphasized that states declining participation would miss out on privately funded scholarships that could benefit multiple educational pathways. The funding would support traditional tuition assistance, homeschooling resources, and specialized services for students with special needs.
The projections indicate that 23 states could collectively lose access to the nearly $23 billion in charitable contributions tied to the federal tax credit over the three-year period. These funds would flow through private donations incentivized by federal tax credits, creating a new channel for education funding that operates outside traditional government appropriations.
The Education Freedom Tax Credit represents a significant shift in education funding policy. Rather than direct government spending, the program encourages private charitable giving by offering federal tax incentives to donors who contribute to approved educational scholarship organizations. These organizations would then distribute funds to families seeking educational alternatives or additional support.
The state-by-state calculator will break down potential losses in both total dollar amounts and estimated number of scholarships that could have been funded. This granular approach aims to help state legislators and governors understand the concrete impact on their constituents.
Supporters of the program argue that it expands educational choice while maintaining state autonomy. States retain the decision whether to participate, but the new analysis underscores the financial trade-offs involved in that choice.
The timing of this analysis comes as states face decisions about implementing the federal tax credit program. State legislatures must determine whether to create the necessary infrastructure to receive and distribute these privately funded scholarships.
The projected $23 billion represents a substantial sum in education funding, particularly for states facing budget constraints. For families seeking alternatives to traditional public schools or requiring additional resources for special needs education, these scholarships could provide meaningful financial relief.
As state governments weigh their options, the interactive calculator provides a concrete tool for assessing the opportunity cost of non-participation. The coming months will reveal which states choose to embrace this new funding mechanism and which will forgo the projected billions in private educational support.
Related: Tech Giants Face Legal Reckoning as Courts Address Youth Social Media Addiction
