A doctoral student at Princeton University was arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport on Thursday, raising questions about the detention of individuals with pending asylum applications.

Eva Yi Xie, a 24-year-old third-year neuroscience student from China, was taken into custody as she prepared to board a flight to New Jersey following her presentation at an academic conference. Her attorney, Kerry Doyle, states that Xie has maintained a pending asylum application for a decade, since her family arrived in the United States when she was 14 years old.

The case presents a stark disagreement between immigration authorities and legal counsel regarding Xie’s status in the country. The Department of Homeland Security maintains that Xie entered the United States on a temporary basis in March 2016 with a departure date of September 15 that same year. The agency’s statement was unequivocal, asserting that Xie has never held valid authorization to study in the United States and that a pending application does not confer legal status.

Doyle disputes this characterization entirely, arguing that her client possessed lawful permission to live, work, and study in the country while her asylum case remained under consideration. The attorney has filed a habeas corpus petition in federal court in Virginia, challenging the arrest as legally baseless and noting that Xie presented neither a flight risk nor a danger to the community that would justify detention without a warrant.

Xie remains in custody at the Caroline Detention Facility in Bowling Green, Virginia. Her detention comes amid the current administration’s broader enforcement actions targeting asylum seekers and others with pending immigration applications, including increased scrutiny of domestic air travel by individuals the government considers to be in the country without authorization.

The young scientist’s work involves complex neuroscience research. According to her academic adviser, Carlos Brody, Xie presented findings at the conference regarding an unexpected connection between decision-making processes in the brain and spatial navigation. Even from detention, she has continued to coordinate with colleagues to ensure her experiments proceed and grant applications move forward.

Brody characterized his student as a gentle and caring individual making substantial contributions to American scientific research. He expressed his belief that she should return to Princeton to continue her work. The university’s graduate school dean, Rodney Priestley, described the arrest as distressing for the Princeton community and confirmed that the institution has arranged legal representation for Xie.

Xie graduated from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2024 with degrees in computer science and mathematics. She has been involved in planning a cognitive computational neuroscience conference scheduled for 2027 in the United Kingdom, indicating the international scope of her academic work.

The case illustrates the tension between immigration enforcement priorities and the status of long-term residents with pending legal proceedings. While Doyle characterizes the arrest as an excessive use of enforcement resources designed to intimidate, federal authorities maintain they are executing lawful immigration policy regarding individuals they consider to be residing in the country without proper authorization.

The outcome of the habeas corpus petition will determine whether Xie’s detention continues or if she returns to her doctoral studies at Princeton. The case raises fundamental questions about the treatment of asylum applicants during the often lengthy adjudication process.

Related: Bipartisan Lawmakers Propose Internet Tax to Fund Rural Broadband Access