Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, a name synonymous with roadside comfort food and quaint retail items, faced a significant decrease in its market value, almost $200 million, following the unveiling of a new logo on Thursday. This new design, a stark departure from the traditional imagery of a man leaning against a barrel, now showcases only the company’s name.

The shares of Cracker Barrel dipped by $8.74, or nearly 15%, during Thursday’s trading session, resulting in a loss of roughly $194.6 million in the company’s overall market value. However, the stock managed to claw back some of its losses in the early afternoon, with shares down $8.19, or 13.9%, to $50.84.

This negative reaction from Wall Street follows Cracker Barrel’s efforts to modernize its image, which includes new menu items and redesigned store interiors. This departure from the chain’s historical, rustic charm, a staple for over 55 years, has taken a more contemporary turn.

According to the company’s website, the man and barrel in the previous logo symbolized an old country store experience. A place where people could congregate and share stories. Now, the company has decided to go in a different direction, with CEO Julie Felss Masino describing the chain as “not as relevant as we once were.”

You May Also Like: Fans Cheated: FTC Says Thousands of Taylor Swift Tickets Illegally Resold by Broker

The company reassures customers that the essence of Cracker Barrel remains the same. The character from the old logo, known as “Uncle Herschel,” will continue to be a prominent figure in their restaurants and menus. The company further stated that its new logo, which will be featured on menus and marketing materials, is more closely tied to the iconic barrel shape and wordmark that started it all.

Despite the company’s reassurances, the new logo has not been without controversy. Conservative commentators, including right-wing podcaster Matt Walsh, criticized the new design as more generic. Marketing experts, too, have expressed their concerns. Kevin Dahlstrom, founder of Bolt Health and a veteran marketing officer, described Cracker Barrel’s rebranding as a “fiasco.”

This development underscores how crucial branding decisions can be for a company’s market value and investor confidence. It raises important questions about the balance between honoring tradition and embracing change in the business world.