A troubling pattern has emerged along the New Jersey coastline as summer draws to a close, one that has local officials concerned about public safety at crowded beaches.
Bay Head Mayor Bill Curtis has issued a warning about a social media trend that involves fishermen deliberately attracting sharks to shallow waters near popular swimming areas. The practice, while not illegal, has raised serious questions about the wisdom of luring apex predators into areas where families gather to enjoy the ocean.
“It’s not illegal to fish here. It’s not illegal to fish for shark, but it is bringing in predators, they’re looking for food and there’s a lot of swimmers here,” Curtis stated, articulating concerns that have been building throughout the summer season.
The trend has gained traction on social media platforms, where videos of close encounters with sharks generate significant attention. In one particularly alarming video that circulated widely, a group of individuals pulled an eight-foot bull shark directly onto the beach for photographs. Such encounters, while providing dramatic content for online audiences, create potentially dangerous situations for beachgoers who may be unaware of nearby predators.
The fishing technique in question involves anglers paddling out to deeper waters, sometimes only 100 yards from shore, where they drop bait in water as shallow as 15 feet. They then return to the beach and reel in the sharks from the shoreline, effectively drawing the animals through waters where swimmers are present.
Captain John Schaible, who operates in these waters, defended the practice. “They are just having fun,” he explained. “They’re not killing them. They’re maybe taking a couple pictures with them and letting them go.”
This perspective highlights a divide between those who view the activity as harmless recreation and officials tasked with ensuring public safety. The fishermen argue they are practicing catch-and-release fishing, a conservation-minded approach that allows them to interact with marine life without causing permanent harm.
However, Mayor Curtis maintains that the fundamental issue is not the legality of shark fishing, but rather the proximity of these activities to swimming areas. “Putting food in the water there for the fish to go after is just luring them closer to shore,” he noted, emphasizing the predictable consequences of introducing bait into coastal waters.
The mayor’s appeal centers on common sense and mutual consideration among beach users. “Common sense and consideration for everybody,” Curtis urged. “Everybody can coexist, just be a little careful with what you are doing.”
As the final weeks of summer unfold, this situation presents a modern challenge for coastal communities: balancing the freedom to pursue recreational activities with the responsibility to maintain safe conditions for all beachgoers. The resolution may ultimately depend on whether social media enthusiasts and traditional beach users can find accommodation, or whether more formal restrictions will become necessary to protect public safety.
Related: New York Judge Halts Mayor Mamdani’s Luxury Home Tax Implementation
