A Florida jury last week convicted a 23-year-old man of first-degree murder in a case that highlights troubling aspects of America’s relationship with abortion that extend beyond the familiar policy debates.
Donovan Faison was found guilty of murdering his pregnant girlfriend, 18-year-old Kaylin Fiengo, and her unborn child after she refused his demands that she terminate her pregnancy. The jury also convicted him of burglary following evidence that he lured Fiengo to Coastline Park in Sanford, Florida in 2022 and shot her in her vehicle. Faison now faces the possibility of the death penalty.
Crime scene investigators reported that Fiengo died beside an ultrasound image of her child. She was approximately 14 weeks pregnant at the time of her death.
The facts of the case, as presented by prosecutors, paint a disturbing picture. After Fiengo informed Faison of her pregnancy through a text message showing two positive pregnancy tests, he responded with immediate anger and demanded she obtain an abortion. Text messages retrieved from Faison’s phone revealed his fury and sense of pressure, complicated by the fact that he was living with another woman who suspected infidelity. In one exchange, prosecutors said, Faison appeared to tell a friend he intended to eliminate Fiengo from his life.
This case raises questions that deserve consideration in our broader cultural conversation about abortion. When abortion becomes normalized as a routine solution to unplanned pregnancy, it may inadvertently provide certain men with an expectation that they can avoid the responsibilities of fatherhood. Women who resist such pressure can face consequences ranging from emotional manipulation to, in extreme cases like Fiengo’s, violence.
Research suggests that a significant portion of abortions may not align with women’s true wishes. Studies indicate that approximately 70 percent of abortions may be unwanted, coerced, or inconsistent with the mother’s values and desires. This data challenges the narrative that abortion represents unqualified empowerment for women.
The prevalence of this “abortion or else” mentality extends beyond states with permissive abortion laws. Florida had enacted a 15-week abortion ban the same year Fiengo was murdered, yet the cultural expectation that abortion serves as a convenient escape from parental responsibility clearly persisted.
Those who advocate for unrestricted abortion access often frame the issue as one of choice. Yet for the unborn children whose lives end before birth, no choice exists. For women like Kaylin Fiengo, who face pressure, coercion, or worse when they choose to continue their pregnancies, the rhetoric of choice rings hollow.
The Fiengo case stands as a stark reminder that abortion policy debates cannot be separated from their cultural consequences. When society treats new life as disposable based on convenience, it may foster attitudes that endanger both mothers and children in ways that extend far beyond clinic walls.
As this case proceeds to sentencing, it serves as a sobering example of how deeply abortion’s normalization has penetrated American culture, with consequences that policymakers and citizens alike must confront honestly.
Related: Former First Lady Discusses Race and Public Perception in Upcoming Style Memoir
