President Donald Trump indicated Tuesday that Republican lawmakers may need to adopt a more flexible approach to the Hyde Amendment, the longstanding policy prohibiting federal funding for abortion services.
The President delivered these remarks during an address to congressional Republicans at the Trump-Kennedy Performing Arts Center, where House GOP members had convened for their annual retreat. In the context of ongoing negotiations regarding health care policy, Trump suggested that the party’s traditionally firm position on this matter might require reconsideration.
“You have to be a little flexible on Hyde, you know that. You’ve got to be a little flexible,” Trump stated. “You’ve got to use ingenuity. You’ve got to work. We’re all big fans of everything.”
The Hyde Amendment has emerged as a central point of contention in current discussions concerning proposed extensions of Affordable Care Act subsidies. Republican lawmakers have consistently maintained that any expansion of health care subsidies remains unacceptable without the explicit inclusion of Hyde Amendment protections.
Montana Senator Steve Daines articulated this position last month, stating that taxpayer dollars should never fund abortion procedures and that he opposes any legislative package lacking robust Hyde Amendment safeguards.
The historical context bears noting. When Democrats enacted the Affordable Care Act, commonly known as Obamacare, the legislation did not incorporate Hyde Amendment provisions, thereby permitting certain taxpayer funding for abortion services. Traditionally, the Hyde Amendment has been attached to the annual Labor, Health and Human Services Appropriations Act, prohibiting both direct funding for abortions and coverage of health insurance plans that include abortion services.
The President’s remarks generated immediate and forceful criticism from prominent pro-life advocacy organizations. Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, one of the movement’s most influential groups, issued a strongly worded response through its president, Marjorie Dannenfelser.
“For decades, opposition to taxpayer funding of abortion and support for the Hyde Amendment has been an unshakeable bedrock principle and a minimum standard in the Republican Party,” Dannenfelser stated. “To suggest Republicans should be ‘flexible’ is an abandonment of this decades-long commitment. If Republicans abandon Hyde, they are sure to lose this November.”
The statement concluded with a direct appeal to both the President and congressional Republicans to maintain their historical commitment to this policy position.
This development represents a potentially significant shift in Republican orthodoxy on abortion policy. The Hyde Amendment, first enacted in 1976, has served as a legislative firewall preventing federal funds from supporting abortion procedures, with limited exceptions for cases involving rape, incest, or threats to the mother’s life. Its application has remained a non-negotiable position for Republican lawmakers across successive administrations.
The question now facing the party is whether pragmatic considerations in health care negotiations will override what has been considered a fundamental principle of conservative governance. The answer may well determine the political landscape heading into the November elections.
Related: White House Expands Venezuelan Oil Agreement Beyond Initial Terms
